Was it not wrong for Judah to have relations with a woman he thought to be a harlot, as the Bible says that he did?

Was it not wrong for Judah to have relations with a woman he thought to be a harlot, as the Bible says that he did?


w73 383-384:  Questions From Readers
● Was it not wrong for Judah to have relations with a woman he thought to be a harlot, as the Bible says that he did?—
In reality, Judah did not have relations with a harlot, but unwittingly took the place of his son Shelah in performing brother-in-law marriage and fathering legal offspring. Consider the background:
After Judah’s second son Onan died in execution of divine judgment, Judah sent his daughter-in-law Tamar back to her father’s home until such time as his third son Shelah was old enough to be united with her. But even after Shelah had grown up, Judah did not give him in marriage to Tamar. So when Judah lost his wife in death, Tamar disguised herself as a prostitute and then seated herself on the road that Judah would be traversing. Not recognizing his daughter-in-law and assuming her to be a prostitute, Judah had relations with her.—Gen. 38:11-18.
Since Tamar was being held in reserve for brother-in-law marriage with his third son Shelah, when Judah learned that Tamar was pregnant he pronounced the judgment of death on her for having prostituted herself. When it came to light that Judah himself had unknowingly made her pregnant, Judah exclaimed: “She is more righteous than I am, [why?] for the reason that I did not give her to Shelah my son.” Judah was not married at the time; he was a widower, and so he was not sinning against a wife of his. And the disguised Tamar he mistook to be an unmarried prostitute, in no sacred bonds of marriage. When the woman whom he assumed to be a prostitute could not be located, he realized that he could fall into contempt, that is, for claiming to have had relations with a temple prostitute, when no such prostitute was known to be thereabouts.—Gen. 38:20-26.
As for Tamar, her course was not an adulterous one. Her twin sons were not considered to be the dishonorable sons of sin, sons of fornication. For, when Boaz of Bethlehem took the Moabitess Ruth in brother-in-law marriage, the elders of Bethlehem said to Boaz: “May your house become like the house of Perez, whom Tamar bore to Judah, from the offspring that Jehovah will give you out of this young woman.” (Ruth 4:11, 12) And so Perez is listed among the respectable ancestors of Jesus Christ. (Matt. 1:1-3; Luke 3:23-33) Perez’ mother, Tamar, was like Ruth in not going sexually after a young man.—Ruth 3:10.
As far as Judah was concerned, he thought he was having relations with a prostitute. In this he was not acting right, for it was God’s original purpose for a man to have relations with his wife and not for the earth to be filled with prostitutes. Still, Judah did not sin in the sense of transgressing a specific command of God’s law, for the Mosaic law was not given until much later.—Gen. 2:24; compare Leviticus 19:29.
The account about Judah and Tamar is not in the Bible to entertain. Rather, it forms an essential part of the historical narrative showing how the human line of descent leading to the promised Christ or Messiah, Jesus, was preserved.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , on by .
Unknown's avatar

About MeekSpaceNG

MeekSpaceNG - free theocratic materials and downloads We've assembled wonderful selection of fun free theocratic multimedia, crossword puzzles, Bible Reading Schedules, Documents, Templates and various useful research tools for Jehovah's Witnesses, and we offer them all to you for free use and distribution. Jehovah’s Witnesses Theocratic Software. With life becoming ever so full and busy these days, easy access to important resources is both a time-saver and an inspiration, MeekSpaceNG has assembled a wonderful selection of downloads for Jehovah's Witnesses, and we offer them all to you for free use and distribution. Many of these aids are practical, others are a source of motivation, and they're all intended for your enrichment, easy research, pleasure and enjoyment. You'll discover a wide variety of different file types in these collections which among others include multimedia, templates, Word and PDF documents. Theocratic Software offerings range from a complete chronology of "The Promised Seed" (Genesis) to personal Bible reading schedules in a variety of formats. You'll even find a Bible timeline for daily use that puts important scriptural references at your fingertips. Simplify organizational duties with templates for Our Christian Life and Ministry, midweek and weekend meetings, announcements or congregation accounts. Assembly and Regional Convention notebooks are available as well as Life and Ministry workbook and worksheets for adults and the kids are equally given prominent attention. Develop Bible reading schedules, outline study programs, and track field service time. From delightful children's activities to inspiring desktop wallpaper, these JW theocratic downloads are engaging and entertaining resources for the whole family. As God's organization is ever more using jw.org as a means to distribute spiritual food, meekspaceNG was created to find ways to alert the reader of the latest information, releases and updates from the official website. However, we don't allow posting of entire articles or magazines here, only links to such articles will be provided. We know there is such a condition as "fair use". This allows for quoting portions and discussing it. Here is the "official" info on fair-use: https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/more-info.html. This rule we are bound to respect to the fullest. However, if in anyway we are overstepping our bounds, we are ready for adjustments. We conclude by saying that this is personal project and is in no way officially connected with jw.org. we are jw friendly. We believes in all the teaching of the Giverning Body of JW's Friends and propaging the ideals and doctrines of the organization as the only Channel Jehovah is using today. We therefore encourage all visitors and users of the blog to visit https://www.jw.org which is the official web for Jehovah's organization.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.